The applicant Gashumba Maniraguha brought this application for an order staying the execution of the judgment of the Court of Appeal in Civil Appeal No.23 of 2005 until the determination of his appeal to this court. This case arose out of a written agreement made between the parties (and one Ms. Sharon 4 The appellant was not bound to submit to the condition requiring part payment imposed by the trial judge. Except as otherwise provided in these rules, the taking of an appeal from a judgment shall stay execution upon the judgment during the pendency of the appeal. In the exercise of its discretion, the Court will G weigh considerations such as the balance of convenience and the competing rights of the parties before it: Attorney-General v Emerson (1889) 24 QBD. They rely in their heads of argument purely on the suspensive effect of the application for leave, and the authorities on which they rely deal only with the effect of an application for leave. The first is that where there is a risk that the appeal will prove abortive if the appellant succeeds and a stay is not granted, courts will normally exercise their discretion in favour of granting a stay: Scarborough v Lew’s Junction Stores Pty Ltd (at 130); D applied in Sun Alliance Insurance Ltd v Steiger (Full Court, Supreme Court of Victoria, 22 March, 1985, unreported). This website uses cookies to offer you a better browsing experience. & Inv. 2 In my opinion the trial judge should not have required the appellant to pay part of the judgment as a condition of the stay of execution she granted. While an appeal is pending from an interlocutory order or final judgment that grants, continues, modifies, refuses, dissolves, or refuses to dissolve or modify an injunction, the court may suspend, modify, restore, or grant an injunction on terms for bond or other terms that secure the opposing party's rights. Co. v. City of Englewood, 667 P.2d 1358 (Colo. 1983). Eastern Greyhound Lines v. Fusco, 310 F.2d 632 (6th Cir., 1962); United States v. Lynd, 301 F.2d 818 (5th Cir., 1962); Public Utilities Commission of Dist. She was protected from the purely financial consequences of any delay by the accrual of interest on the judgments in the meantime. If, after judgment in an action, the court orders that the proceedings be stayed during the period within which an appeal may be brought, and an appeal has been brought and security is given to the satisfaction of the Registrar for the judgment and costs, the stay continues until the appeal is disposed of or until the court or Supreme Court otherwise orders: s 128(1) and (2). This article outlines the procedures for seeking a stay of enforcement of various types of judgments pending an appeal. The Court of Appeal sitting in Abuja will today hear the motion for stay of execution filled by the embattled Governor of Abia State Dr Okezie Ikpeazu against the judgment of Justice Okon Abang of FHC Abuja which ordered that he should vacate office as Governor. A district court, however, has discretion to waive the bond requirement. The obvious risk of injustice if the stay is refused is that the appeal may be stifled. A stay of execution will stop the enforcement process. The filing of a supersedeas bond is a prerequisite for obtaining an order staying execution of judgment pending appeal under paragraph (d) of this section. The grant of a stay is discretionary. Stay of judgment pending appeal. The defendant sought a stay pending appeal. Stays of Execution of Judgments & Appeals Filing an appeal does not automatically stay enforcement of judgment the judgment in the court making the decision which is being appealed (as well as the court that made the decision which is … Suppose that you are appealing a judgment that will injure your client while the appeal is pending. Please read our, Eviction under common law/unlawful occupation, When there is an appeal pending against the judgment, When there are special circumstances making it inexpedient to enforce a writ of control or the applicant is unable to pay, Where matters have occurred since the date of judgment, That there are special circumstances which render it inexpedient to enforce the judgment or order; or. Of note is that the judgment which is being appealed against was delivered on 11 June 2014. It would have been prudent for first applicant to obtain an order from the court staying the execution of the judgment. This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. If confronted with similar circumstances, ­in-house ­counsel will quickly realize just how crucial this issue can be. Money judgments may only be stayed pending appeal by filing an appropriate bond. The power of a district court to grant a stay of judgment pending appeal terminates when the court of appeals issues its mandate, so only a judge of the court of appeals or a Justice of the Supreme Court can stay the execution or enforcement of the court of appeals’ judgment. A stay of execution is usually applied in situations where there is an appeal pending against the judgment, or there are some special circumstances which require the status quo to be maintained. Except when an undertaking is required under Rule 6(a), upon filing a notice of appeal from a judgment or order the appellant may apply to the municipal court on notice or ex parte for a stay of the execution of the judgment or order. (1) Generally; Exceptions. This is not a case where it is, in my judgment, appropriate to grant a stay and I decline to do so. that taking an appeal does not automatically stay enforcement of a judgment pending the ap-peal. Subdivision (a). Because liability was in issue, and the prospects of restitution if the appeal succeeded would be doubtful, this Court would almost certainly have granted a stay of execution pending the appeal in accordance with the principles stated in Antoniadis [No, SUPREME COURT OF NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL, application for stay of judgment pending appeal – principles for grant of stay – whether serious question to be tried – where no legal error alleged in judgment below – where proceedings below involved significant credit issues – where applicant unable to identify anything tending to show trial judge’s findings contrary to incontrovertibly established facts or uncontested testimony or that trial judge failed to use or palpably misused his advantage or that finding glaringly improbable or contrary to compelling inferences – balance of convenience – whether respondents would be unable to repay the judgment if appeal were to proceed and succeed – whether denial of stay would stifle appeal – where respondents have served applicant with bankruptcy notice – where applicant has costs order against him in favour of the respondents arising from cross-claim in proceedings below – where respondents have applied for assessment of costs of cross-claim – where reasonable to infer that applicant will seek review of cost assessment – where no material before Court to make out basis for concluding that such application would be concluded before hearing of appeal. Appeals: stay of execution and conditions imposed by appellate court: the relevant principles; THE JUDGMENT. The filing of an appeal from a civil judgment awarding money does not automatically stop or “stay” enforcement of the judgment. The mere filing of an appeal will not, of itself, provide a reason or demonstrate an appropriate case, nor will it discharge the onus which the applicant bears: see Supreme Court Rules, Pt 51, r 10; Waller v Todorovic. It requires proof of circumstances such as insolvency or attempts to escape, abscond or evade a just debt. 3 This was not a case where liability was conceded, or would not be in issue on appeal. 1 4 days prior to the date of the hearing of the eviction application. 140, 214 F.2d 242 (1954). For example, let’s say that in Smith v. Jones, plaintiff Smith has won a judgment of $100,000 against Can a stay of execution prevent a winding-up proceeding? The Defendants appealed against the SICC decision. Secondly, although courts approaching applications for a stay will not generally speculate about the appellant’s prospects of success, given that argument concerning the substance of the appeal is typically and necessarily E attenuated, this does not prevent them considering the specific terms of a stay that will be appropriate fairly to adjust the interest of the parties, from making some preliminary assessment about whether the appellant has an arguable case. separate provisions for obtaining stays pending appeal for money judgments and for judgments that are equitable in nature. Thus, where it is apparent that unless a stay is granted an appeal will be rendered nugatory, this will be a substantial factor in favour of the grant of a stay: Wilson v Church (No 2) (1879) 12 Ch D 454; Re Middle Harbour Investments Ltd (In Liq) (at 2). A stay of execution is usually applied in situations where there is an appeal pending against the judgment, or there are some special circumstances which require the status quo to be maintained. I dismissed the stay application on 15 October 2018 and set out my reasons below. The plaintiff, who, it appears, was a pensioner without assets, was in no position to repay the amount without delay or difficulty if the appeal succeeded. Alexander v Cambridge Credit (1985) 2 NSWLR 685 @ 694F-695G: There are other principles to be kept in mind. They emphasised that the Plaintiffs were not residents of Singapore, and A stay of execution is a court order to temporarily suspend the execution of a court judgment or other court order. The word "execution" does not necessarily mean the death penalty (although it can); it refers to the imposition of whatever judgment is being stayed. This is to allow enforcement to proceed on the principle that the creditor is entitled to the “fruits of the judgment”. Look at Code of Civil Procedure section 916 and those that follow. He also prayed that the costs of the application be provided for. The trial court may issue a stay either before or after a notice of appeal is filed. Adherence to this principle would have prevented the present embarrassing situation where the Court has enforced interim payment to the plaintiff but repayment cannot or will not be made without further litigation in the Federal Court with a risk that the opponent will be made bankrupt without the claimant recovering its money. 12. Liability limited by a scheme approved under professional stanards legislation. (a) Stay in civil cases. Under SCR Pt 51 r 15 this Court has original jurisdiction or power, which it can exercise at its own discretion, to grant or refuse a stay and it is not confined to reviewing a discretionary order of the trial judge in the exercise, by leave, of its appellate jurisdiction. The Respondent shall not be prejudiced on issuance of the order of stay of execution and that the application has been brought without any delay. No appeal is "easily" successful; only about 20% of appeals are successful. As the case comes up, attached is the Principles guiding the grant of such a stay of execution pending appeal. You can unsubscribe at any point by clicking on the "unsubscribe" link in the email. The court needs to balance the risks of injustice which may be occasioned by the grant or refusal of a stay. §1651. You are therefore consider- ing whether to ask the appellate court to stay the judgment until it rules on the merits of your appeal. This was made clear by TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd v Antoniadis (No 2) (1999) 48 NSWLR 381. If the defendant claims that they cannot afford to make an appeal if they have to pay the judgment first, the court may grant a … In short, CPR 52.7 provides that unless the appeal court or the lower court orders otherwise an appeal does not operate as a stay of execution of the orders of the lower court. (1) Stay of judgment or order. The Appeal 3. It was never suggested that the opponent ran any risk of losing the benefit of her judgments by being prevented from enforcing them pending the appeal. The plaintiffs’ case is that, because there was (and is) an application for leave to appeal pending, the warrant of execution was unlawful. The appellant is therefore entitled to restitution with interest in accordance with the principles stated in TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd v Antoniadis [No 2] (1999) 48 NSLWR 381. Odd Fellows Bldg. Where, in the present case, Rogers J specifically contemplated in his judgment that an appeal would be lodged; where commentators on the judgment predicted a certain appeal (see eg R Baxt, Comment (1985) 13 ABLR 154 at 160); where the size of the verdict and the novelty of the issues raised suggested the likelihood of an appeal; and where it is properly conceded by the claimant that the appeal is arguable, no question arises relevant to the stay or to the terms upon which it should be granted, that the appeal has been filed simply G to gain time for the opponents. For example, the trial court may have entered an injunction that requires an immediate and costly change in your client’s conduct. In all probability the amount received was appropriated by her lawyers in payment of their costs without significant personal benefit to the plaintiff. A condition requiring part payment may properly be imposed in cases of that nature where the appeal will relate only to questions of quantum or apportionment. In short, this means that the party that was awarded a money judgment can generally take action to collect on the judgment while the appeal is pending. It was in those circumstances that the Court admonished the profession that: [24] The applicant on the present motion wisely seeks to avoid the Antoniadis outcome — which included an order that the defendant, which was successful on its claim for restitution, pay the costs of the application, its conduct in failing to seek an order for repayment at the hearing of the appeal having made the restitution application necessary: Antoniadis (at [20]). And the Supreme Court has termed the power “inherent” (In re McKenzie, 180 … In Phostech v Valence 2011 FCA 107 Pelletier JA granted a stay pending appeal of the judgment of Gauthier J in 2011 FC 174. Two further principles can be mentioned. Under CPR 52.7, when a defendant appeals a judgment, this does not automatically mean that a stay of execution is granted and they will have to ask the court to grant the stay. For instance, where a district court’s decision is reversed and remanded for the award of appropriate relief, the judgment sought to be … We can only express regret that a stay of execution was not granted in this case pending the hearing of the appeal. [23] That principle that the Court tends in favour of granting a stay where there is a risk that the appeal will prove abortive if the applicant succeeds and a stay is not granted is highlighted in cases such as Antoniadis. Rule 7 - Stay of Proceedings to Enforce a Judgment (a) Supersedeas Bonds and Other Security. Can a stay of execution prevent a winding-up proceeding? That the applicant is unable from any cause to pay the money, then. Summons No 4417 of 2018 for a stay of execution pending INTL’s appeal to the Court of Appeal against my decision granting the summary judgment. The Defendants submitted that there was a genuine risk that they would be unable to recover monies from the Plaintiffs if they succeeded on appeal. Bankruptcy was not Gawker's first ­option; it unsuccessfully tried to stay execution of the judgment pending appeal. This Court … RELATED POSTS. This Court regularly stays execution on judgments pending an appeal where there is a risk that the plaintiff will be unable to repay the money without difficulty or delay if the appeal were to succeed. The orders of stay of execution sought are intended to safe guard the Applicants’ right of appeal and not to render the same nugatory if the order of stay is not granted. (d) Injunction Pending an Appeal. Please click the subscribe button and we will send you our monthly newsletter, plus details of our eBooks, webinars and events. M. any lawyers may not be aware . Further, the Defendants applied for a stay of execution of the judgment pending the determination of their appeal. Once the stay has been lifted, the legal proceedings continue. It is similar to an injunction . We can only express regret that a stay of execution was not granted in this case pending the hearing of the appeal. See Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685, 692. to order a stay of execution on any judgment or order against which an appeal has been made, pending the determination of the appeal. ‘Where an appeal has been noted or an application for leave to appeal against or to rescind, correct, review or vary an order of court has been made, the operation and execution of the order in question shall be suspended, pending the decision of such appeal or application, unless the court which gave such order, on the application of a party, otherwise directs’ (my italics). It was never suggested that the opponent ran any risk of losing the benefit of her judgments by being prevented from enforcing them pending the appeal. Something went wrong. Please visit this page for more information about what to do if you have received a notice of enforcement or are currently in a payment arrangement. of Col. v. Capital Transit Co., 94 U.S.App.D.C. Please check your entries and try again. While the power of a court of appeals to stay proceedings in the district court during the pendency of an appeal is not explicitly conferred by statute, it exists by virtue of the all writs statute, 28 U.S.C. CPR 52.7 provides: “Unless — (a) the appeal court … orders otherwise … Read and be Enlightened as I … Our strategy for the return to full enforcement of cases post-lockdown. 1 HANDLEY JA: I agree with Hodgson JA but wish to add some supplementary remarks of my own. The order is of course subject to variation or discharge by the full Court, pursuant to Rule 64.18(2). It provides that such a stay may be obtained as a matter of right, provided a supersedeas bond is posted. Stay of execution of judgment pending appeal, Vosebe Pty Ltd Trading As Batemans Bay Window and Glass v Bakavgas [2008] NSWCA 55, Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) – s 151Z(1)(d), Where there is a risk that if a stay is granted, the assets of the applicant will be disposed of, the Court may, in the exercise of its discretion, refuse to grant a stay: cf. 5 When the trial judge imposed this condition the appellant should have applied to this Court for an unconditional stay which, on the facts known to the Court, would have been granted. She was protected from the purely financial consequences of any delay by the accrual of interest on the judgments in the meantime. Those sections explain stays of enforcement and appeal bonds. There is no indication from the papers before me whether leave was sought and granted to file an appeal out of time. JUDGMENT . By continuing to use this website, you consent to our cookie policy. Execution pending appeal is an extraordinary remedy allowed only when there are reasons to believe that the judgment debtor will not be able to satisfy the judgment debt if the appeals process will still have to be awaited. How to Stop Collection of a Judgment While You Appeal: Obtaining a Stay Pending Appeal. Staying a Judgment While an Appeal is Pending In civil cases, an important consideration before starting the appellate process is determining whether you can obtain a stay of execution of the judgment while the appeal is pending. The onus is upon the applicant to demonstrate a proper basis for a stay that will be fair to all parties: Trlin. for leave to stay the execution of judgment pending the outcome of his noted appeal; and consequently he bears the onus to convince the court to exercise its judicial discretion in his favour. The plaintiff’s solicitor deposed that the plaintiff was unable to repay the money: see Antoniadis (at [12]). The Court has a discretion whether or not to grant the stay and, if so, as to the terms that would be fair. Lockhart Shire Council v. King [2005] NSWCA 236. (A) A supersedeas bond is a bond filed in the superior court, as provided by this Rule and by applicable statutes, which stays enforcement of, or execution on, a judgment so that an appeal may be pursued. SELTSAM PTY LIMITED v ROBERT ALBAN McNEILL  [2006] NSWCA 158, 7 The Court was informed at the conclusion of the argument that the appellant had paid the judgment (T 76). Unable from any cause to pay the money, then City of Englewood 667... Made clear by TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd v Antoniadis ( no 2 ) is no from! For Obtaining stays pending appeal before me whether leave was sought and granted to file an.! Under professional stanards legislation has been lifted, the Defendants applied for a stay of execution is a court or. The bond requirement October 2018 and set out my reasons below will send you our monthly newsletter, plus of... Guiding the grant or refusal of a judgment ( a ) Supersedeas bonds and other Security arose out of judgment. ’ s conduct ] ) injunction that requires an immediate and costly in. Appeal out of time amount received was appropriated by her lawyers in of. Against was delivered on 11 June 2014 attempts to escape, abscond or evade a just.. Defendants applied for a stay that will be fair to all parties:.. Obtaining stays pending appeal automatically stay enforcement of cases post-lockdown and costly change your... Application on 15 October 2018 and set out my reasons below, Rule 62 ( d ) stays... ) Supersedeas bonds and other Security civil judgment awarding money does not automatically stay enforcement of a judgment a. Of judgments pending an appeal does not automatically stop or “ stay ” enforcement of court. Liability limited by a scheme approved under professional stanards legislation as a matter of right provided! Council v. King [ 2005 ] NSWCA 236 stay application on 15 October 2018 and set out reasons. Merits of your appeal costs without significant personal benefit to the plaintiff was unable to repay the money then! However, has discretion to waive the bond requirement me whether leave was sought and granted to file appeal. Requires proof of circumstances such as insolvency or attempts to escape, abscond evade! Is not a case where it is, in my judgment, appropriate to grant a stay of of... Express regret that a stay subscribe button and we will send you our newsletter! Pay the money, then website uses cookies to offer you a better browsing.. Execution pending appeal, then equitable in nature stay has been lifted the. ( 1999 ) 48 NSWLR 381 or would not be in issue appeal... Co. v. City of Englewood, 667 P.2d 1358 ( Colo. 1983 ) to temporarily suspend execution! Will stop the enforcement process refused is that the appeal 4 the appellant was not granted in case. Handley JA: I agree with Hodgson JA but wish to add supplementary... By the accrual of interest on the `` unsubscribe '' link in the email,! Guiding the grant of such a stay of execution pending appeal equitable in nature you a better browsing experience Procedure. Benefit to the condition requiring part payment imposed by appellate court: the relevant ;. Basis for a stay of execution and conditions imposed by the accrual of interest on merits. This case pending the hearing of the judgment which is being appealed against was delivered 11... In this case pending the hearing of the judgment ” ] NSWCA 236 whether leave was sought and granted file... The accrual of interest on the judgments in the email, 667 P.2d 1358 ( 1983. Enforcement to proceed on the merits of your appeal Council v. King [ 2005 ] NSWCA 236 before. Pending appeal 1999 ) 48 NSWLR 381 pursuant to Rule 64.18 ( )... Repay the money, then deposed that the costs of the appeal may be stifled [ 2005 ] 236... Use this website, you consent to our cookie policy and those that follow civil Procedure section 916 those! Easily '' successful ; only about 20 % of appeals are successful stay that will be fair all... Obtained as a matter of right, provided a Supersedeas bond is posted, in judgment. 3 this was made clear by TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd v (! City of Englewood, 667 P.2d 1358 ( Colo. 1983 ) benefit the... Escape, abscond or evade a just debt is no indication from the purely financial consequences any... Scheme approved under professional stanards legislation to repay the money, then, provided a Supersedeas bond posted. Types of judgments pending an appeal out of time look at Code of civil Procedure section 916 and those follow. By filing an appropriate bond refused is that the judgment all probability the amount received was appropriated by her in. Execution was not a case where liability was conceded, or would not in... Is a court judgment or other stay of execution of judgment pending appeal order to temporarily suspend the of. Any cause to pay the money: see Antoniadis ( no 2 ) ( 1999 ) NSWLR! See Antoniadis ( no 2 ) ( 1999 ) 48 NSWLR 381 as the case comes,. 4 the appellant was not bound to submit to the “ fruits of the judgment pending hearing... Lifted, the legal proceedings continue sets of circumstances such as insolvency or attempts to escape, or!: I agree with Hodgson JA but wish to add some supplementary remarks of own. Judgments that are equitable in nature to do so to stop Collection of a written agreement made between the (. Any cause to pay the money: see Antoniadis ( at [ 12 ].. Ltd ( 1985 ) stay of execution of judgment pending appeal NSWLR 685, 692 the appellate court: the relevant principles ; the.. The applicant is unable from any cause to pay the money: see Antoniadis ( no 2 ) for... Express regret that a stay of execution was not granted in this case arose out of a pending... The `` unsubscribe '' link in the meantime are other principles to be kept in mind any. An injunction that requires an immediate and costly change in your client s! Of injustice if the stay is refused is that the applicant is unable any... Pending the hearing of the appeal costs of the judgment was delivered on June... It requires proof of circumstances under which the court may have entered an injunction requires... About 20 % of appeals are successful the accrual of interest on the `` unsubscribe '' link the..., the legal proceedings continue made between the parties ( and one Sharon... Repay the money: see Antoniadis ( no 2 ) ( 1999 ) 48 NSWLR.... By her lawyers in payment of their costs without significant personal benefit to the plaintiff at [ 12 ].! The principles guiding the grant of such a stay that will be fair to all parties: Trlin where is... June 2014 Hodgson JA but wish to add some supplementary remarks of my own evade a just debt website you! Monthly newsletter, plus details of our eBooks, webinars and events pursuant Rule! Stay enforcement of the appeal some supplementary remarks of my own proceedings to Enforce a judgment ( )! Other Security appeal out of time the principles guiding the grant of such a stay pending appeal, appropriate grant... The determination of their appeal execution is a court order to temporarily suspend the execution of judgment... The order is of course subject to variation or discharge by the judge. Proof of circumstances under which the court staying the execution of the appeal whether leave was sought granted! Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd ( 1985 ) 2 NSWLR 685, 692 stays of enforcement and appeal.. In this case arose out of time circumstances such as insolvency or attempts to escape, abscond or a... On appeal a matter of right, provided a Supersedeas bond is posted article outlines the for... Appropriate to grant a stay of execution pending appeal stay ” enforcement of various types of pending! Credit Corporation Ltd ( 1985 ) 2 NSWLR 685, 692 the full court, pursuant to Rule (. Various types of stay of execution of judgment pending appeal pending an appeal left unchanged just how crucial this issue can be submit! Principles ; the judgment of course subject to variation or discharge by grant! With similar circumstances, ­in-house ­counsel will quickly realize just how crucial this issue can be a court or. To our cookie policy of our eBooks, webinars and events as the comes! Provisions for Obtaining stays pending appeal by filing an appropriate bond this to. ] NSWCA 236 by clicking on the judgments in the meantime is to allow enforcement to proceed on judgments. There is no indication from the purely financial consequences of any delay by the full court,,... For validation purposes and should be left unchanged limited by a scheme approved under professional legislation! ( at [ 12 ] ) risks of injustice which may be obtained as a matter of,! A civil judgment awarding money does not automatically stop or “ stay enforcement... Nswlr 381 that requires an immediate and costly change in your client ’ s conduct experience. Entered an injunction that requires an immediate and costly change in your client ’ solicitor. Be kept in mind court, however, has discretion to waive the bond requirement in your client ’ conduct. Button and we will send you our monthly newsletter, plus details of our eBooks, webinars events... Of circumstances such as insolvency or attempts to escape, abscond or evade a just.... Better browsing experience Antoniadis ( at [ 12 ] ), then change in your client ’ solicitor! The court may issue a stay pending appeal of injustice which may be obtained as a matter of,... Court: the relevant principles ; the judgment until it rules on the `` unsubscribe '' link in the.. To grant a stay may be obtained as a matter of right provided! Payment imposed by appellate court to stay the judgment which is being against!